I really think you should experiment with the tape. It's much, much less messy.
The tape thickness becomes a factor, regardless of how thin it is.
Artist's spray adhesive works fine. It's not messy if not used excessively, and it allows you to adjust before it sets. You can tack the ends with a touch of CA if you feel it isn't secure enough. I learned this from Fine N Scale, as this method is what was used to build the masters for the freight car castings.