Jason
My small home layout runs on a Digitrax DB150 which is really a booster rather than a full blown command station. That said, it will only do "on the main" programming and does not read CV's. I would try to change some other CV, say momentum to see if that works. Also, maybe just see if you can change the address to a new two digit one.
As I remember "good" on the DB150 only means that the CV packet was sent. There is no real feedback verification.
I rarely use the DB150 to program. My goto is a separate programming track with a Digitrax PR3 and JMRI Dcoder Pro.
Conrad