The
Demand Products foam anchors arrived this morning. They might be expensive, but they are definitely strong! Demand anchor is shown top left, and middle left in the foam with a #10 x 1-1/4" driven tight with an impact driver. Cannot be driven in with a hand screwdriver, required a T-40 bit in the impact driver. Good for #6 through #10 sheet metal screws. Mfr. says good to 1/4", but I think that might be pushing it. Problem as you can see in the second photo, the flip side of the test foam, is they are too long - 2-1/4" - to use for 2" foam alone.
Did another test with the drywall anchors and glue, and it's only good for #6 screws, hand-tightened. I tried a #8 with the impact driver and proceeded to tear it out. A perfect world would have the Demand anchors at 25ยข each and 1-3/4" long, but that's not going to happen, so I'm still good with the drywall anchors.