I did mine pretty much 'stock', and following Max's instructions that he wrote for the Keystone (or I never would have gotten through it).
It's definitely 'fat' on width but to me not objectionably so.
http://pennsyrr.com/kc/model/ghq_l1/GHQl111.jpghttp://pennsyrr.com/kc/model/ghq_l1/GHQl110.jpgI did that a long time ago now, but it was a landmark event, as I'd just looked at that kit in the box for a couple years too scared to take it on. The confidence I got from that certainly took me in a lot of different directions later. The level of fearlessness I have on destroying my Jamco 4-6-2 was planted here, that's for sure.
But still, I think it looks pretty good, could be better, but not enough to drive me crazy. Now, I had the original pewter tender body with the casting mark line across it, cleaning that mess up, well THAT drove me crazy.