Is this water product any good?

[tom mann]

http://www.featherrivertrains.com/cgi-bin/webstore/shop.cgi?ud=BAgGAw8KDw4HCRQUAAYKB19REx1LU0YfTENdVkReQ1RXUFdJeEJUXxQUDwMMBgoLBwgBARMU&storeid=1&hide=HASH(0x8536de0)&cols=1&categories=06006-06355&&c=detail.htm&t=main.detail.htm&itemid=MW-18oz

I've never heard of this, but it claims that it doesn't have the problems that other water products have.

What about this:

http://www.featherrivertrains.com/cgi-bin/webstore/shop.cgi?ud=CQYEAw8KDw4HCRQUAAYKB19REx1LU0YfTENdVkReQ1RXUFdJeEJUXxQUDwMMBgoLBwgBARMU&storeid=1&hide=HASH(0x853bf00)&cols=1&categories=06006-05038-00340&&c=detail.htm&t=main.detail.htm&itemid=WS-C1211

[mmyers]

Haven't tried it. There was a guy selling this stuff at Timonium in October the booth was near Klien's. He may be there next month.

Martin Myers

[noonan]

A few comments here:
http://www.trainboard.com/grapevine/archive/index.php/t-61484.html

[Ian MacMillan]

I have read about the Magic water on a few sites and saw a demo of it. It seems to work pretty well and I have seen nothing but rave reviews on it. I will be using it instead of EnviroTex lite on my new layout.

[tom mann]

I have read about the Magic water on a few sites and saw a demo of it. It seems to work pretty well and I have seen nothing but rave reviews on it. I will be using it instead of EnviroTex lite on my new layout.

That's good enough for me.  Thanks.

[Ian MacMillan]

I have read about the Magic water on a few sites and saw a demo of it. It seems to work pretty well and I have seen nothing but rave reviews on it. I will be using it instead of EnviroTex lite on my new layout.

That's good enough for me.  Thanks.

There is also a pretty good write up on it in this months Model Railroad News

[UP_Phill]

I ordered a couple pints a year or so ago. I haven't had a chance to use it on the layout as of yet but did create a few puddles on my sons Warhammer diorama. This stuff is much easier to use than Envirotex and looks fantastic.

[central.vermont]

I have read about the Magic water on a few sites and saw a demo of it. It seems to work pretty well and I have seen nothing but rave reviews on it. I will be using it instead of EnviroTex lite on my new layout.

That's good enough for me.  Thanks.

If you listen to everything he says Tom your...............well you know.  : ;D ;D ;D

Sounds like some nice stuff though.
Jon 

[Chulvis]

I saw it a demo of it while in Denver last summer and it convinced me to bring it in the shop.They had side by side comparisons of their product against a few others and I thought the Magic Water was the best of the group.

I have not tried it myself though.

[saui]

Tom,
try it....Dave is a nice guy. He don't sell punk.